Finexus Returns & Risk Profile
2026-06-07

Monarch’s Upside Edge Meets a History of Deep Drawdowns

Why the casino‑operator’s current high‑volatility rally may mask lingering risk
MCRI Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc.
In this report
01
Returns Overview
Period returns, alpha, cumulative performance, distributions
P. 2-3
02
Volatility Analysis
Annualized volatility, downside deviation, drawdowns
P. 4-5
03
Beta & Correlation
Trailing, upside, downside beta, systematic risk
P. 6-7
04
Risk-Adjusted Returns
Sharpe, Sortino, Calmar, Information, Treynor
P. 8-9
05
Market Regime Analysis
Bull/bear behavior, capture ratios
P. 10-11
06
Investment Highlights & Risk Summary
Executive summary, risk flags, rankings
P. 12-13
Returns Overview
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Return Performance
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) delivered strong absolute returns across all horizons, markedly outpacing its Consumer Cyclical sector benchmark. Over the past month it rose 2.28% versus a sector gain of 4.87%, generating 7.26% alpha; the outperformance accelerated to 28.35% vs 15.25% (22.95% alpha) over three months and remained robust at 42.36% versus 23.36% (36.26% alpha) year‑to‑date. Longer‑term performance continued the trend, with total returns of 83.24% over two years (48.02% sector return, 55.71% alpha) and 106.11% over five years (34.30% sector return, 72.57% alpha), indicating consistent excess gains relative to its peer group.
Period Returns vs S&P 500 & XLY
Monthly Returns Heatmap
MCRI
MCRI generated positive alpha in every interval, with the most pronounced short‑term divergence occurring over the 3‑month and 6‑month periods where alpha exceeded 22%. The long‑term horizon shows sustained outperformance, delivering a 72.57% alpha advantage over five years, underscoring its ability to create value beyond sector trends.
Returns Overview
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Return Charts
Volatility Analysis
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Volatility Profile
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) exhibits markedly higher price variability than the broader market, with an annualized volatility of 38.74% compared to the S&P 500's 17.78%, indicating more than double the typical stock‑price swings. The downside profile is also pronounced: a downside deviation of 29.96% and a historic maximum drawdown of -75.06% over a ten‑month window (Feb 2020 to Dec 2020) reflect substantial vulnerability during market stress, with the recovery taking roughly nine months. While short‑term volatility remains elevated—60‑day vol at 38.01% exceeds the 252‑day average of 32.31%—the longer‑term figure still surpasses the S&P 500 benchmark, underscoring a persistently higher risk environment for this business.
Volatility Metrics
MCRI
The company’s annualized volatility of 38.74% is more than two standard deviations above the S&P 500's 17.78%, signaling that investors should expect larger price swings on a regular basis. Downside risk metrics reinforce this view: a downside deviation of 29.96% and a maximum drawdown of -75.06% illustrate deep, prolonged losses during market downturns, with the 2020 episode lasting nearly ten months before full recovery. The current 60‑day volatility (38.01%) remains above the trailing 252‑day average (32.31%), indicating that recent price movements are more erratic than the longer‑term norm, which itself is already high relative to the market.
  • MCRI's annualized volatility is over double the S&P 500 benchmark.
  • Downside deviation of 29.96% signals pronounced sensitivity to negative market moves.
  • Maximum drawdown of -75.06% reflects severe historical loss potential and long recovery time.
  • Short‑term (60‑day) volatility exceeds its own 252‑day average, suggesting heightened recent risk.
  • Even the longer‑term volatility (32.31%) remains well above market norms.
Positive Characteristics
  • The volatility metrics are transparent and quantifiable, allowing investors to price risk explicitly.
  • Despite high volatility, the stock has demonstrated a full recovery from its deepest drawdown within nine months, indicating resilience under favorable conditions.
Volatility Analysis
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Volatility & Drawdown Charts
Beta & Correlation
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Beta Profile
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) exhibits a trailing beta of 1.178 versus the S&P 500, positioning it in the upper range of market‑like sensitivity (0.8–1.2). This indicates that, on average, the stock moves roughly 18% more than the broad market during normal conditions, reflecting an aggressive tilt relative to a defensive profile (<0.8). The upside beta of 1.046 versus a downside beta of 1.389 reveals pronounced asymmetry: the equity tends to underperform in falling markets while delivering modest excess gains when the market rallies, a pattern that heightens downside risk for investors. The R‑squared of 0.292 and correlation of 0.54 with the S&P 500 show that less than one‑third of MCRI’s price variation is explained by overall market movements; the remaining two‑thirds stems from idiosyncratic factors specific to the casino‑resort business. When benchmarked against its consumer‑cyclical sector (XLY), the sector beta of 0.952 suggests near‑par exposure to sector dynamics, yet the sector correlation (0.527) and R² (0.278) are almost identical to the market figures, underscoring that both market and sector drivers explain a similar modest share of variance. Consequently, the bulk of risk resides in company‑specific elements such as regulatory changes, discretionary spending trends, and operational performance.
Beta & Correlation Metrics
MCRI
The trailing beta of 1.178 places MCRI on the aggressive side of market sensitivity, implying amplified reactions to broad equity movements. However, the pronounced downside beta (1.389) relative to upside beta (1.046) signals that losses in bearish periods are likely to be larger than gains in bullish periods, a key consideration for risk‑averse investors. With an R‑squared of 29.2%, systematic risk accounts for roughly one‑quarter of total variance, while idiosyncratic risk dominates at 70.8%. This high idiosyncratic component reflects the company’s exposure to factors like gaming regulation, tourism cycles, and capital‑intensive resort operations that are not captured by market or sector indices.
  • Trailing beta of 1.178 signals aggressive market exposure but remains within the market‑like range.
  • Downside beta (1.389) exceeds upside beta (1.046), indicating greater vulnerability during market declines.
  • R‑squared of 29.2% shows that only about a third of price movements are driven by systematic factors; diversification benefits are limited.
  • Systematic risk constitutes 29.2% versus idiosyncratic risk at 70.8%, highlighting the predominance of company‑specific drivers.
  • Sector beta (0.952) is slightly lower than market beta, suggesting that sector dynamics contribute marginally less to overall volatility.
Positive Characteristics
  • Near‑par sector beta indicates MCRI tracks consumer‑cyclical trends without excessive sector concentration risk.
  • Upside beta above 1.0 (1.046) suggests the stock can capture modest gains when broader markets rise.
Beta & Correlation
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Rolling Beta
Positive Notes

Near‑par sector beta indicates MCRI tracks consumer‑cyclical trends without excessive sector concentration risk.

Upside beta above 1.0 (1.046) suggests the stock can capture modest gains when broader markets rise.

Risk-Adjusted Returns
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Risk-Adjusted Performance
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) delivers modest risk-adjusted returns relative to standard benchmarks. A Sharpe ratio of 0.578 falls well below the >1.0 threshold that signals a favorable trade‑off between total volatility and excess return, indicating that the stock’s reward per unit of overall risk is limited. Nonetheless, the Sortino ratio of 0.748 exceeds the Sharpe figure, suggesting that downside volatility is less pronounced than total volatility and that the equity has managed to preserve capital during adverse market moves better than its overall risk profile would imply.
Risk-free rate: 3.63% (Fed Funds Rate)
Risk-Adjusted Metrics
MCRI
MCRI ranks first—and only—in this single‑company analysis for risk-adjusted performance, albeit with modest absolute metrics. The Sharpe ratio of 0.578 signals that the stock generates roughly $0.58 of excess return for each unit of total risk, while the higher Sortino ratio (0.748) highlights a relatively gentler downside profile, implying investors are being compensated more for upside volatility than they are penalized for losses. The Calmar ratio of 0.347 points to a low return relative to the maximum historical drawdown, indicating that periods of steep declines have eroded a sizable share of cumulative gains.
  • Sharpe ratio (0.578) is below the desirable >1.0 level, reflecting limited excess return per unit of total risk.
  • Sortino ratio exceeds Sharpe (0.748 vs 0.578), indicating a more favorable downside‑risk profile than overall volatility suggests.
  • Calmar ratio (0.347) signals that historical drawdowns have been severe relative to average returns, highlighting potential capital erosion during market stress.
  • Information Ratio (0.404) is below the >0.5 benchmark, suggesting that any alpha generated has not been consistently strong enough to offset tracking error.
  • Treynor ratio of 19.027 reflects a high return per unit of systematic risk (beta), but without an accompanying beta figure its absolute significance remains limited.
Positive Characteristics
  • Higher Sortino than Sharpe demonstrates that downside volatility is relatively contained.
  • Treynor ratio indicates strong compensation for market‑related risk, assuming a typical equity beta.
Risk-Adjusted Returns
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Rolling Sharpe & Sortino
Positive Notes

Higher Sortino than Sharpe demonstrates that downside volatility is relatively contained.

Treynor ratio indicates strong compensation for market‑related risk, assuming a typical equity beta.

Market Regime Analysis
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Regime Behavior
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) exhibits a distinct pattern across market regimes, delivering solid outperformance in bullish environments while moderating losses during downturns. In bull markets the stock generates an average monthly return of 3.27% under low‑volatility conditions and 2.67% when volatility is elevated, reflecting its sensitivity to broad equity momentum but also a slight dampening when market turbulence rises. During bear periods the company’s downside exposure is limited, with an average loss of just -0.43% in volatile declines versus a sharper -3.37% in orderly downtrends, indicating a defensive tilt that softens losses when markets are falling calmly.
Current Market Regime: Bull-HighVol
Bull-LowVol = calm uptrend • Bull-HighVol = volatile uptrend • Bear-LowVol = orderly decline • Bear-HighVol = crisis
Regime Returns & Capture Ratios
MCRI
In the current Bull‑HighVol regime—characterized by an S&P 500 above its 50‑day SMA and realized volatility above median—MCRI’s historical average return of 2.67% per month suggests it can still capture upside despite heightened market swings, though the pace is modestly slower than in low‑vol bull markets. The stock’s upside capture ratio of 139.1% means it outperforms the S&P by roughly 39% on the upside, while a downside capture of 90.5% shows it sheds less than 10% of market losses during declines, yielding a capture ratio of 1.54 that underscores its asymmetric risk‑return profile.
Market Regime Analysis
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Regime & Capture Charts
Regime Timeline
  • MCRI’s upside capture (139.1%) exceeds the S&P 500 by a wide margin, indicating strong participation in market rallies.
  • Downside capture remains below 100% (90.5%), limiting losses relative to the broader index during bear phases.
  • The capture ratio of 1.54 confirms that the stock captures significantly more upside than downside, a favorable asymmetry for investors.
  • Performance deteriorates modestly in high‑volatility bull markets (2.67% vs 3.27% in low‑vol), reflecting sensitivity to market turbulence.
  • In bear regimes, especially Bear‑LowVol, the stock experiences deeper declines (-3.37%) than in Bear‑HighVol (-0.43%), suggesting it is more defensive when volatility spikes.
Positive Characteristics
  • Strong upside capture provides robust participation in equity uptrends.
  • Downside capture below 100% offers a defensive buffer during market corrections.
  • Capture ratio above 1.0 signals favorable risk‑adjusted performance across regimes.
Investment Highlights & Risk Summary
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. (MCRI) — Summary & Implications
Monarch Casino & Resort, Inc. delivered a robust 1‑year total return of 42.36%, generating an alpha of 23.36% versus the S&P 500 and outpacing its consumer‑cyclical peers by 36.26%. The stock’s upside capture of 139.1% against the broader market indicates strong participation in bullish phases, while a downside capture of 90.5% suggests it has limited exposure to market declines. However, the company’s risk profile is marked by elevated volatility (38.74% annualized) and an extreme historical drawdown of –75.06%, reflected in an asymmetric downside beta of 1.39 versus an upside beta of 1.05. Investors should weigh the attractive return potential against the heightened tail‑risk and consider how this risk‑return trade‑off fits within a diversified portfolio.
Summary Dashboard
Investment Highlights
  • 1Y total return of 42.36% translates to a 23.36% alpha over the S&P 500, demonstrating strong absolute performance.
  • Upside capture ratio of 139.1% shows the stock participates more than proportionally in market rallies.
  • Downside capture of 90.5% indicates relative resilience during market declines, limiting loss exposure compared with the index.
  • Sector alpha of 36.26% signals outperformance versus the consumer‑cyclical ETF (XLY), positioning the company as a sector leader.
Risk-Return Rankings
MCRI HIGH
High return with strong upside capture but marked by extreme volatility and deep historical drawdown.
Strength: Outstanding 1‑year alpha of 23.36% and sector outperformance.
Concern: Maximum historic drawdown of –75.06% and asymmetric downside beta of 1.39.
Key Takeaways
  • Monarch’s return profile exceeds both the broad market and its consumer‑cyclical peers, driven by strong upside participation.
  • The Sharpe ratio of 0.578 is modest, indicating limited excess return per unit of risk relative to a benchmark Sharpe >1.0.
  • A deep historical drawdown and high volatility suggest significant tail‑risk that could impair capital preservation.
  • Downside beta above 1.0 signals the stock may fall faster than the market in adverse environments.
PORTFOLIO IMPLICATIONS
Given its high upside capture, Monarch can serve as a growth‑oriented satellite within a broader equity allocation, potentially enhancing returns during bullish cycles. However, its elevated volatility and deep drawdown history warrant limiting exposure to a modest position size or pairing it with low‑beta, defensive holdings to mitigate tail risk and smooth overall portfolio volatility.
MCRI
Related Reports
Finexus Important Notice

Disclaimer

This report is generated by Finexus and is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.

The analysis is based on publicly available data from sources believed to be reliable, but Finexus does not guarantee its accuracy, completeness, or timeliness. Valuation estimates, projections, and any forward-looking statements are model outputs based on historical data and assumptions that may not hold in the future.

Past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers should conduct their own independent research and consult a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decision. Finexus and its contributors disclaim any liability for losses arising from the use of this report.

Link copied to clipboard